Monday, February 18, 2008

Brief Update

Last week was one of those "too busy for blogging" weeks, but here's a quick hello in the midst of interviewing members for the next issue of the MVFHR newsletter and having planning discussions about our next big research project, which I hope to write more about in the next few weeks.

Check back here soon for upcoming posts about MVFHR's work regarding the death penalty expansion bill in New Hampshire, our perspective on the U.S. government's decision to seek the death penalty for the six Guantanamo detainees, talking about families of the executed to a large audience of lawyers at the Capital Case Defense Seminar in California ... and more.

Meanwhile, our thoughts are with the families of the victims of the shooting at Northern Illinois University. MVFHR member Jennifer Bishop has been quoted in several news stories in connection with her work to reduce gun violence. Here's one of the articles.

Monday, February 11, 2008

A Collapse in the Heart and Soul

Probably the worst charge leveled at family members of murder victims who oppose the death penalty is that they must not have loved their family member all that much, or be all that devastated by the murder, if they don't want to see the killer executed. I challenge these critics to pay real attention to the voices of victims' family members who oppose the death penalty, to hear how they talk about their experience and their feelings.

Here's one vivid example. Antoinette Bosco's son and daughter-in-law were murdered in their Montana home in 1993. In the introduction to her book Choosing Mercy: A Mother of Murder Victims Pleads to End the Death Penalty, Antoinette Bosco writes:


I got the news of the brutal murders on August 19, and that day I learned a new definition of torment. I had had to accept much death in recent years -- my father, my sister-in-law, my son Peter. Death from almost any cause, even from accident, can somehow be dealt with rationally. But if the death is caused by murder, there is a collapse in the heart and soul that cannot be described.

For murder is the entrance of the worst imaginable evil into your home, into all the safe places of your life, forever shattering any illusion you might ahve had that good can protect you from evil. Evil becomes all too real to you and never again can you even for an instant question its power. My beloved son and his beautiful wife were dead at the hand of someone I could only believe to be, at that moment, an agent of Satan.

I found myself screaming, sometimes aloud, sometimes with silent cries tearing at my insides. I tormented myself, wanting to know who was the faceless monster that had brought such permanent unrelenting pain into my family. I wanted to kill him with my own hands. I wanted him dead.

But that feeling also tormented me, for I had always been opposed to the death penalty. I felt now I was being tested on whether my values were permanent, or primarily based on human feelings and expediency. With God's help, I was able to grasp the truth again, that unnatural death at the hands of another is always wrong, except in a case of clear self-defense. The state is no more justified in taking a life than is an individual. And so armed, I found myself speaking out on a national platform, pleading against the death penalty for anyone.

Friday, February 8, 2008

But Not Like This

"We'd known death, but not like this. I'd never been in favor of the death penalty, but I wanted that man to hurt, the way he'd hurt her. I wanted him to hurt the way I was hurting. But after a while I wanted to know who it was, what kind of a monster would do a thing like this."

MVFHR member Hector Black is featured on StoryCorps today, talking about the murder of his daughter, his initial rage at the man responsible for the murder, his gradual desire to understand that man as a human being, and his opposition to the death penalty. The story is airing on NPR this morning as well; check your local listings. You can hear Hector on StoryCorps's site here.

Wednesday, February 6, 2008

Spanish, French, Italian

For the Third World Congress Against the Death Penalty last year, we developed versions of the MVFHR brochure in Spanish, French, and Italian. It was useful to have those translations available at the World Congress, and we hope it can be useful to have them available for other occasions and situations. Think about ways you might get these translated brochures into the hands of people who speak those languages, and let us know if you have the ability to translate our brochure into other languages, too.

Keep us posted! If you distribute our brochure at, say, a gathering of Spanish-speakers in the U.S., we would love to hear about it.

Monday, February 4, 2008

End Injustice, Not Lives

I've meant to post this for the past couple of weeks but haven't gotten to it until now: MVFHR members Derrel Meyers and Naomi White had a great op-ed piece published in the San Jose Mercury News on January 18, the first day of the National Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty conference. The piece is titled "We should be devoted to ending injustice, not ending more lives":

Twelve years ago, our 23-year-old son was murdered. Today, we are attending a national gathering with other family members of murder victims working to end a different kind of killing: the death penalty. We can think of no better way to honor our son's life.

On the evening of Jan. 19, 1996, our only child, Joshua "JoJo" White, was driving home from work at Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Academic Middle School in San Francisco where he counseled and tutored troubled adolescents. At 16th and Carolina streets, an agitated youth confronted JoJo and his three friends. JoJo and his friends tried to reassure the young man, but he pulled a gun from his coat and fired into the car. JoJo's last words before the fatal shot was fired were, "Peace brother, one love." The bullet pierced his heart and he died within seconds in the arms of his friend Equipto.

During his life, JoJo had developed an empathy with troubled youngsters. It grew from his own experiences in the playgrounds and classrooms of San Francisco. At age 12 he was diagnosed with dyslexia and was placed in special education classes with other "problem" children. Being a typically competitive adolescent he was at first angered and shamed to be considered part of society's lesser achievers. But it was in those classrooms that his most important education began. He learned from the inside how it felt to be looked down upon by others. Over the following years, JoJo saw how devastating poverty, inequality and violence can be to young hearts and tender egos. He saw that many of these children were being tracked into a wasteland of disrespect, despair, drugs, violence and prison. He saw these problems and wanted to be part of the solution. But sadly, he became one of the many victims of this system.

We don't know who killed our son; there's no name, no fingerprints, not even a clear description since it happened so fast in the dim light of evening. But we do know why he died. And we do know that the young man who killed him was as much a product of our society as the gun he used. Having lost our only child to murder and having lived with that horror for 12 years, we deeply understand the heartbreak and even the rage of others who have experienced similar loss. We hear their cries for justice. We, too, want justice, but a justice that excludes vengeance, more killing - and more injustice.

On Jan. 10, the California Commission on the Fair Administration of Justice, which is charged with making recommendations on how we can improve our criminal justice system, began a three-hearing investigation into the death penalty. The hearing exposed deep racial and ethnic inequalities in the death penalty system that will take millions of dollars to address - on top of the millions it already costs to maintain the broken process. How much better would it be to use that money to help at-risk youth, to solve the countless murders that go unsolved, to provide grief counseling for the loved ones of murder victims? The millions of dollars that are wasted on the death penalty each year could be better spent on programs that actually help prevent crime and offer positive alternatives to youth. We seek a justice that changes the social and economic conditions that foster violence.

Today, in San Jose, we are attending the annual conference of the National Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty. We are meeting with other parents who have buried children, other survivors of murder victims. We have different stories and come from different walks of life, but we are united by a common goal: ending the killing, in the name of justice.

Friday, February 1, 2008

Last Statement

Today, at the Texas Prison Museum, a photography exhibit called Last Statement will open and run indefinitely. It features photographs of families of victims, including MVFHR member Bud Welch, and photos of family members of the executed, including MVFHR members Rena and Ireland Beazley, Bill Vaught, Lois Robison, and Melanie Hebert (all of whose relatives were executed in Texas) and MVFHR member Tamara Chikunova, whose son was executed in Uzbekistan.

An article in The Huntsville Item describes the exhibit:

A photography exhibit featuring individuals directly affected by capital crimes or capital punishment will open at the Texas Prison Museum on Feb. 1.

The exhibit, produced by photographer Barbara Sloan, features pieces that chronicle executed inmates’ final statements and pieces of individual case history.

“The name of the exhibit is ‘Last Statement,’ and I’ve labeled it as a continuing study of the families of victims and offenders executed on death row,” Sloan said “It’s a black and white photography fine art presentation. Nothing is done by a computer and there is nothing digital involved.”

Sloan said the exhibit features 16 photographs, divided evenly between the families of victims and the families of the executed.

The photographs are paired with paragraphs of text which provide the basic crime data from each case and a portion of the last statement of the person executed.

“I would try to pick something that related to the statement of the person in the photo,” she said. “The largest part of the text was the statement of the person in the photo. The photo may include the mother of a child who was murdered or the mother of an offender who was executed.”

Sloan said she felt her work on “Last Statement” was an incredible experience in her career.

“I’ve found this to be an incredible, sensitive project,” she said. “It is not about the death penalty — that was not the purpose of the project. The purpose was to show compassion for the families who are victims of a capital crime and the families of those suffering the loss of a person executed for a capital crime.”

Wednesday, January 30, 2008

Testifying in New Hampshire

In New Hampshire yesterday, victims' family members Renny Cushing (Executive Director of MVFHR) and Arnie Alpert (chair of the New Hampshire Coalition Against the Death Penalty) testified against a bill that would expand the state's death penalty. From an article in today's Concord Monitor:

A state senator and Attorney General Kelly Ayotte urged lawmakers yesterday to support a bill seeking to expand the state's narrow death penalty law to include murderers who kill multiple victims. Critics, meanwhile, challenged the proposal as immoral and expensive.

The bill would expand the state's number of death penalty cases considerably. Since 2003, there have been eight multiple-victim murders. Go back further, to 1996, and the number climbs to 18. By contrast, the state is currently prosecuting its first two death penalty cases since 1990, and the state hasn't executed anyone for nearly 80 years.

The bill's sponsor, Republican Sen. Joseph Kenney of Union, said his proposal is a response to this summer's triple killing at an Army-Navy store in Conway, for which Michael Woodbury of Maine is serving a life sentence without parole. Ayotte said the absence of a provision about multiple killings from the state's current death penalty law is a "glaring omission."

The state's existing law covers six types of murder: murder of a law enforcement or judicial officer; murder for hire; murder in prison while already serving a life sentence; and murders during a kidnapping, rape or drug sale.

"We have a narrow (death penalty) statute, and that is appropriate," Ayotte said. "But this should be covered."

Ayotte introduced an amendment to Kenney's bill that would include murderers who kill multiple people either at once or over a period of time. A sister of one of the victims in the Conway case spoke in support of the bill. Jennifer Walker Blake, whose brother James Walker was killed, said Woodbury's prison sentence is better than he deserves, especially since it includes meals, shelter and other amenities. It's unfair, she said, that someone who kills three people gets the same sentence as someone who kills one person.

Kenney's bill drew more opponents than supporters yesterday. Three supported it; five didn't. It will likely face a tough fight on two grounds: moral and financial.

Church leaders and others argued the first point.

Diane Murphy Quinlan, chancellor of the Catholic diocese, said the use of capital punishment contributes to the culture of violence. "State-sanctioned killing in our name diminishes all of us," she said.

Renny Cushing of Hampton, the founder of Murder Victims' Families for Human Rights, said the state should be proud that it hasn't executed anyone for nearly 80 years. "Killing murderers will not bring anyone back," said Cushing, whose father was murdered. "What it does is creates another grieving family."

Read the rest of the article here.

Tuesday, January 29, 2008

To Every Corner of the World

The Death Penalty Information Center recently posted a link to a collection of articles published last November by the Inter Press Service (IPS). The collection is titled "Crime and Justice: Abolishing the Death Penalty," and contains articles about work against the death penalty in Europe and Central Asia, Africa, the Mideast and the Mediterranean, Asia and the Pacific, Latin America and the Caribbean, and the United States.

Among the many articles is an interview with Bill Pelke about The Journey of Hope and about his opposition to the death penalty as the family member of a murder victim, and an article titled "Executions Create Generations of Victims," which includes excerpts from MVFHR's report Creating More Victims: How Executions Hurt the Families Left Behind.

In the introduction, Mario Lubetkin, Director-General of IPS, writes:

It was a historic year. In 2007 the tide of opinion against the death penalty gathered in strength as never before, sweeping to every corner of the world. The number of abolitionist countries rose. The number of executions declined. Long in place moratoriums held and new ones came into force. And as the year drew to a close, proof of this seemingly irresistible tide of change came with the powerful vote in the U.N. for a global moratorium on executions. The IPS 'Death Penalty Abolition Project', supported by the European Union, has recorded the voices of many of those who have played a key role in this fast-moving journey towards a death-penalty-free world. In doing so, IPS has been guided by the purposes and principles contained in the Charter of the United Nations, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the Convention on the Rights of the Child.

Monday, January 28, 2008

Eating Me Up Inside

We've added another Tennessee member to our Gallery of Victims' Stories: Shane Truett, whose brother Timothy was murdered in 1992. Shane, an attorney, works with the Tennessee Justice Project, a nonprofit organization devoted to criminal justice reform with a specific emphasis on death penalty issues.

In an op-ed piece in the Tennessean this past May, Shane wrote, "I have struggled for years with my feelings on capital punishment. All the hatred and anger I felt as a result of my brother's murder was eating me up inside. Eventually, I found out my brother's murderer had died in prison. His death didn't make me feel any better, as I once thought it would. I realized that there are some wrongs that just can't be made right again."

Thursday, January 24, 2008

Working with Prisoners

Two Massachusetts members whom we've just added to our Gallery of Victims' Stories have in common the fact that they have chosen to work against violence by working with prisoners in some way. Milton Jones, whose son Elijah was killed in 1993, founded the Community Re-Entry Program for prisoners preparing to be released from county jails. Milton, who testified against reinstatement of the death penalty in Massachusetts a few months ago, says, "“At first, we felt that we wanted the killers dead. But at some point, I looked at what being in that frame of mind was doing to me and my family. What does it make me if I continue to harbor those feelings? It makes me no better than the person who did the crime. All the death penalty really does is perpetuate hurt and pain and violence."

Dick Nethercut, whose daughter Jaina was killed in 1978, has been leading Alternatives to Violence workshops in prisons since 1992. Dick also testified against reinstatement of the death penalty in Massachusetts; he says, “From my perspective, the death penalty only adds to the suffering of the victim’s family, rather than lessening it. I believe the work I do now in prison and with ex-prisoners honors and gives significance to my daughter's life."